9/11 Comic Strip Reviews
I’ll leave the surveys of the television and the blogosphere to those that are bigger and better at it to begin with and do the 9/11 themed comic strips. It’s more my niche anyway, as if that weren’t already glaringly obvious. I’ll add to the list as I come across more, email me if you find one I’ve missed. I’ve always thought that reading the comic strips is a highly subjective experience; I’ve no other way to explain the continued existence of Cathy. So if I’ve dumped on one of your favorites, my apologies.
BTW, the dumbasses at King Features run their strips with a two-week delay, so they don’t make the list. Out of those, I know that Dennis the Menace and The Family Circus ran 9/11 themed strips. They were about as bad as you would expect. It’s too bad I can’t link to Rhymes With Orange, though.
Kevin & Kell – Nicely done
User Friendly – Too sappy
Over The Hedge – Get back to the jokes
Jerk City – Do what you do best, or the terrorists win
The Boondocks – You tell ‘em Grandpa
Preteena – Never heard of this strip, but that was kind of humorous
Gasoline Alley – When you can’t think of anything, you can always try yanking on the heartstrings
Dick Tracy – When you can’t think of anything, there’s always the tiny little note of condolence. To be fair, the note is more or less what I expect to see in a serial comic
Annie – Note and heartstrings done unexpectedly well.
The Big Picture – I don’t know the strip, but this doesn’t feel well done
Pluggers – Filler
Grand Avenue – Filler
Real Life Adventures - Above average filler
Overboard – What to do when there’s nothing to say
The Born Loser – Barely more than filler. The Born Loser is one of those strips that once your eye catches it, you read it, but you always wish you hadn’t. It feels like a waste of time.
Rudy Park – That would be a nice tradition
Sheldon – Touching
Warped – Filler
Luann- Cleverly done, if you follow the strip.
Nancy – Possibly the worst filler yet.
Alley Oop – Typical serial comic note to the reader
The U.S. of Play – If it wasn’t 9/11, you wouldn’t know it was about 9/11. I think that makes it decent filler.
Raising Duncan – Meh.
Committed – I think he thinks I should be doing something else.
Trevor – Clever Trevor
Pearls before Swine – Decent tug on the heartstrings
Planet Earth and Other Tourist Traps – I know the feeling
Mudpie – Competing with B.C. for the lucrative Christian non-funny funnies market
Superosity – That’s a lot of words for four little panels
Ozzy and Millie – Another meme pastiche, anti-war lyrics meet skyline meet couple watching sunset. It’s a big canvas brain dump.
Everything Jake – I bet he had to go buy a new pencil
The Surburban Jungle – Filler
LookWhatIBroughtHome – Sticking with what they know best
Life’s so Rad – Blurry Filler
Boxjam’s Doodle – Good on you, Boxjam.
Fat Jesus Weird, but it made me laugh.
Mallard Fillmore – Aflac
Foxtrot – Blended in almost too well. I totally missed it the first time I saw it. Thanks, Oreta!.
Editorial Cartoons
Matt Davies – Extremely well done
Stuart Carlson – Arty
Paul Conrad – Reminds me of Herblock
Bill DeOre- Needs sound effects
Bruce Hammond – Animated. Nice and simple
Walt Handelsman – Lots of black ink in 9/11 editorial cartoons
David Horsey – Spot on
Dick Locher – Draws anger really well
Dick Marlette – Feels like an awkward pastiche to me
Glenn McCoy – Nice Vulture
Jack Ohman – WTF?
Joel Pett – The person I think hasn’t learned anything is not the same person Joel thinks it is.
Steve Sack – Pretty. I don’t know anything about art, but that looks like an excellent use of charcoal and pen to me.
Ben Sargent – His people always look like frogs to me.
Ann Telnaes- Preach it, sister.
Tom Toles – Kind of utopian for Tom
Randy Bish – Hope he didn’t spend a lot of time on that
Mike Luckovich – Hope they’re coming for me, next.
Henry Payne – Nicely executed skyline
Rob Rogers – “Ignore the coverage” seems to be a wide spread meme.
Jeff Stahler – But that doesn’t mean that its execution can’t be just as bad as some of the others.
Ed Stein – Oh, well done. Bravo!
Sean Delonas – Nice underground comix feel. Love the evil Bert.